A Tom Thomson Mystery

Nov 24, 2021 | History, Publications | 0 comments

By Fred Blair

​If you found the name “Tom Thomson” on the back of a landscape painting, would you think of the Group of Seven?  This is a wandering tale about a painting and the possible connections between four landscape painters and Stephen Leacock.

In 1888, the Rev. Richard W.E. Greene arrived in Orillia to become the incumbent at St. James Church.  Richard was known to have been painting while at Trinity College between 1866 and 1871 where he organized at least one group exhibition.  About 1878, he studied landscape painting part-time at the Ontario College of Art and began to take part in painting outings with other Toronto artists.  While in Orillia, Richard started the Orillia Sketch Club, taught painting in his home, and invited painters from Toronto to come up and judge the fall fair art exhibits.  Franklin Carmichael studied with Richard who would also have introduced him to the city painters.  Richard himself continued to make landscape painting trips with his friends from Toronto into Muskoka and Georgian Bay.

Franklin Carmichael apprenticed in his father’s carriage factory and later became head of the painting department before he left Orillia in 1911.  Ruth Thomson praised the “feathered script” that Franklin had done on her father’s bread wagons.  The two families may have known each other well.  Franklin would return to Orillia to marry his childhood sweetheart and would later return to visit friends and family.

Richard Greene left Orillia in 1911 for Toronto as well.  Franklin may have introduced Richard to Tom Thomson and other members of the Group of Seven there.  In 1930, Ruth visited Franklin’s studio that he shared with Tom Thomson and other artists in Rosedale Valley.  In the OMAH collection we have one of Ruth’s landscape paintings.  We now have the probable connections between the four landscape painters.

Richard visited friends in Orillia and maintained his friendship with Stephen Leacock. After the publishing of Sunshine Sketches of a Little Town in 1912, Richard asked Stephen if Dean Drone was based upon him but Stephen declined to answer.  Richard was working on a painting of the Leacock boat house at that time.

The painting of a schooner, pictured here, was titled, “Canon Green leaving Orillia for Toronto” and was inscribed, “Tom Thomson from Rev. Canon Green 2nd Oct. 17.”  Richard, while a young man, had been the captain of the Governor General’s schooner on Lake Ontario, so it is quite likely that Richard left Orillia by sail.  The painting was not dated or signed, which was common for Richard’s paintings.  The Leacock Museum has no documentation on how the three Greene paintings there came to be in their collection.

There was at least one Tom Thomson living in the Orillia area who may or may not have been related to Ruth.  It was not Tom Thomson of the Group of Seven as he died on July 8, 1917.  Which Tom Thomson received the schooner painting and why was it in Stephen’s house?

Happy Birthday to Dr. Nancy Ironside!

Happy Birthday to Dr. Nancy Ironside!

Happy Birthday to Dr. Nancy Ironside! In honour of her birthday on July 24, we pay tribute to Nancy Retired physician and anesthesiologist, environmentalist, naturalist and... To many, Dr. Nancy Ironside needs no introduction. Without fanfare, Nancy has made a huge...

Two Horse Rides from Orillia to Coldwater

Two Horse Rides from Orillia to Coldwater

Corduroy Road Over a Swamp in Orillia Township, Ontario Ware, Titus Hibbert, 1810-1890 Picture, 1844, English Pen & brown & blue inks, grey wash, over pencil. Toronto Public Library Digital Archive, in the Public DomainBy Fred Blair Jacob Gill and his...

Community Difference-Maker: Erin Dixon and the Gojijing Roundtable

Community Difference-Maker: Erin Dixon and the Gojijing Roundtable

Community Difference-Maker: Erin Dixon and the Gojijing Roundtable Three thousand years ago, Orillia was populated by the Wendat or Huron people, whose settlement extended all around Lake Couchiching, which they called Gojijing.  As colonizers arrived, the lives of...

Andrew Borland, War of 1812 Veteran

Andrew Borland, War of 1812 Veteran

By Fred Blair On June 18, 1812, the United States declared war on the British.  Many recent American settlers in Upper Canada, like the Borlands, had to consider where their loyalties lay.  By law, all the males between 16 and 60 in the province were required to serve...

Thomson Family: John Thomson

Thomson Family: John Thomson

By Trish Crowe-Grande, Chair OMAH History CommitteeThe Thomsons, one of Orillia’s influential founding families, rose in prominence in the early days when lumbering was the big industry and dominated the commercial life of the community.Born in Scotland in 1831, John...

Happy Birthday Franklin Carmichael!

Happy Birthday Franklin Carmichael!

Introduction   Happy 131st Birthday, Franklin Carmichael for May 4th, 2021. Fellow Orillians are on a quest to learn more about you. Carmichael was a Renaissance man: husband, father, teacher, philosopher, artist in oil, watercolour and graphite, designer of book...

Sue Mulcahy – 100 Years Young!

Sue Mulcahy – 100 Years Young!

  Happy Birthday Sue!   Lucille (Sue) Mulcahy, stalwart member of our community, turns 100 on March 14th! OMAH and Lakehead University join together to honour Sue and to celebrate her many accomplishments and contributions over those years, that have so enriched...

Past Pandemics : How They Have Shaped Us

Past Pandemics : How They Have Shaped Us

The current Covid-19 pandemic has caused unprecedented changes in social interaction and commerce.  With all the changes resulting from self-isolation, social distancing, travel restrictions, reduced shopping trips, increased on-line shopping, working at home and...

Christmas Cards from Franklin Carmichael

Christmas Cards from Franklin Carmichael

The OMAH collection is a treasure trove of artifacts, often generously donated by those who recognize their importance to local history. These gems teach us about our past and individuals who played a part in it. Orillian, Franklin Carmichael, a founding member of the...

Sir Sam Steele: Letters from the Past

Sir Sam Steele: Letters from the Past

  Context is everything, particularly when judging historical figures such as Sir Sam Steele. The purpose of the following article is to inform and educate, and not to remark on commemoration or legacy. There are always new discoveries related to our local history....