
Trish Crowe-Grande
It is that time of year when the leaves change colour, pumpkins and fall mums appear on porches and there is a crisp coolness in the air. If you have taken any walks in your local neighbourhood or drives around town, you may have noticed that houses are starting to take on that eerie sensation. People are starting to decorate their homes for Hallowe’en in anticipation of little ghosts and goblins out and about on October 31st, shouting out “trick-or-treat”! The Halloween spirit is on display.
Did you know there are rumours that have been swirling around Orillia and surrounding area for decades about the supernatural nature of some local buildings, in and about town, as well as the beautiful St. Columbkille’s Church in Uptergrove. It is said, that once the sun goes down, the church transforms from beautiful to spine-chilling in an instant. It doesn’t necessarily need to be ‘Hallowe’en Eve’ to bring out the phantoms, according to urban legends.

In 1855, Irish and Scottish Catholic immigrants founded St. Columbkille Parish, located in the hamlet of Uptergrove. It was the first Catholic parish in the area. The original frame church was torn down and the present brick edifice was constructed in 1905. This beautiful Gothic structure stands majestically on a hill far back from the road and can easily be viewed by all when driving on Highway 12 east from Orillia.
It was the parishioners over a hundred years ago who began spreading ghostly tales that the church was haunted and these tales have been circulated ever since. Today the church is deemed haunted by some local residents. There have been accounts of ghost sightings, shadowy figures that will suddenly appear, creaking doors and eerie music that will waft down from the organ loft.
The burial vault has been known to creak and blow open on cold, windy days. These reports, along with a rectory that has stood empty for over 100 years, and a graveyard holding both the original settlers and dotted with unknown graves, has created a rich folklore of a supernatural nature in an otherwise quiet country parish.
There have also been numerous reports of shadowy sightings of a figure wearing a black hat that floats through the choir area, creating chills for those who had observed. Mysterious candlelight has been seen flickering from the windows on stormy nights. Many believe the spirit responsible is that of a former priest, who, according to legend pledged to complete a specific number of sermons, died before he was able to attain that number. Now, some parishioners say he is returning to fulfill that promise.

Some present-day parishioners feel the church’s haunted reputation is a result of Irish descendants who were simply great storytellers that wanted to create their own legend. However, in the spirit of good fun, parishioners have included several ghost stories in their published history celebrating their 150th jubilee.
Whether the legends are real or a result of over-active imaginations, the ghost of St. Columbkille’s has created a rich folklore of the supernatural and added a unique character to this otherwise quiet, quaint country church.


If you’d like to learn about some of the eerie happenings within Orillia’s downtown, join OMAH on Friday October 29 between 5 and 9pm for “Spooky Stroll,” a one-hour guided walk between the museum and the Opera House. Click HERE to register.
Sources:
SF9 #46, St Columbkille Roman Catholic Church: Is it Haunted? www.geocaching.com
“Haunted Simcoe” by Coady Fitzgerald. October 27, 2020
“Divine Ghost Stories” by Elizabeth Shearer. October 30 2006
Simcoe County has Haunted Past. October 29, 2009
The Barons of Dallas
By Fred Blair, OMAH History Committee member and Family Historian In 1835, James Dallas and his family sailed from Scotland to New York City, travelled up the Erie Canal, and made their way to Orillia. In September he purchased 100 acres between Mississaga Street and...
City unveils its newest art commission: Crossroads, Connections and Intersections
The City’s Art in Public Places Committee along with Mayor Don McIsaac unveiled the sculpture “Endorphin” by artist Camille Rajotte on April 20, 2023. The sculpture is one of nine works being installed across the city over the next several months as part of the...
A Murder Plot and the Canadian Knights of the Ku Klux Klan
Currently on display at the OPP Museum, these items were seized by OPP members during investigations. The grey Canadian Knights of the Ku Klux Klan (KKK) t-shirt was seized as part of the 1982 investigation into forged passports that turned into a killer for hire....
CHIEF YELLOWHEAD’S JUSTICE IN 1832
Indians and Canoe at Coldwater River, 1844, Titus Hibbert Ware (Toronto Public Library)By Fred Blair, OMAH History Committee member and Family Historian This is a story of an accidental killing in 1832, an unsatisfactory trial verdict, and how Chief William Yellowhead...
THE TAITS OF ORILLIA
Andrew Tait, 1896. Photo from the Orillia Museum of Art & History Archives By William Leslie, Guest Contributor This is the story of the Tait family. William Tait, his wife, Mary and family left Scotland in 1848 for Canada, travelling from Liverpool to New York...
THE DAVENPORT BROTHERS
By Fred Blair, OMAH History Committee member and Family Historian About 1810, 20-year-old Benjamin Davenport, his younger brother William, and William’s wife Sarah arrived in Upper Canada (Ontario) as former Black slaves. William was born in Virginia about 1792 and...
THE ORILLIA WINTER CARNIVAL – A HISTORY
By P. (Trish) Crowe-Grande, Chair: OMAH History CommitteeWinter weather can bring short, bone-chilling days and long, dark nights with the sun setting much too early. For many of us, it can be challenging to find engaging activities that don’t involve bingeing an...
THE CANADA-AUSTRALIA SERIES
By David TownIt was another proud first for Orillia, and an astounding accomplishment – but as John Miller stepped off the train at the Orillia platform the only people there to greet him were his family. He had single-handedly negotiated, organized, and managed the...
2022 Year-end Message from the OMAH History Committee
by Trish Crowe-Grande, Chair, OMAH History Committee While this past year saw COVID-19 restrictions ease, the OMAH History Committee listened to its audience and continued to offer its popular History Speaker Series as well as the Annual Carmichael Art History...
MASSEY FAMILY HOME CHILDREN OF CANADA
Albert (Bert) Scaife Massey – OMAH CollectionBy Fred Blair, OMAH History CommitteeIn 1868, Anne Elizabeth Massey was born in Chelsea, London, England. She was the daughter of George and Elizabeth Massey. By 1891, the family had moved to Fulham, London and “Annie”,...